Some Foods Are Better Left In Our Memories

Not what we say about our blessings, but how we use them, is the true measure of our thanksgiving.  ~W.T. Purkiser

We Ate What??

Page Created: 11/22/2026 Page Last Updated: 11/22/2026 14:00

iIn the olden days when I was a kid, I remember these items!

Thanksgiving dishes that have gone to the wayside over the years

1. Creamed pearl onions

Creamed pearl onions appeared in cookbooks as far back as 1896, according to online records, and were a familiar addition to Thanksgiving spreads by the 1920s.

The dish pairs tender onions with a buttery white sauce similar to French béchamel. Frozen pearl onions later made it easier to prepare. The old-fashioned side still has devoted fans, according to Bon Appétit.

Thanksgiving dishes that have gone to the wayside over the years

 

2. Oyster stuffing or dressing

Oyster dressing called for combining shucked oysters and their brine with classic stuffing ingredients including bread, celery and spices.

Homemade Thanksgiving Stuffing Made with Bread and Herbs seen on table alongside other side dishes.
Before sausage added flavor and depth to the stuffing, Americans turned to oysters, which were easily purchased from refrigerated railcars. (iStock)

It was a Thanksgiving staple in the 1800s, when oysters were regularly available for purchase from refrigerated railcars, Food52 reported.

The dish, with roots in British culinary traditions, fell out of favor in the Northeast as oyster populations declined and tastes shifted toward ingredients such as sausage.

Thanksgiving dishes that have gone to the wayside over the years

 

3. Mincemeat pie

Before pumpkin and apple pie solidified their place at the table, there was a meaty dessert contender.

Mince pies with pastry star tops arranged in a muffin baking tray.
Mincemeat pie's richly spiced filling once included meat, dried fruit and animal fat. (iStock)

The filling of mincemeat pie was originally a sweet and savory mix of dried fruit, spices, citrus and meat — often beef or mutton — with suet, the fat of the meat.

"When we were kids my mom would always do mincemeat pie for both Thanksgiving and Christmas and we hated it," one commenter on Reddit recalled.

Over time, meat disappeared from many recipes, leaving only the richly spiced fruit filling behind, though the pie's name still hints at its historic roots.

Thanksgiving dishes that have gone to the wayside over the years

4. Aspic

Long before Jell-O, cooks prepared savory aspics by simmering collagen-rich bones, skin and feet until the broth set, according to the Michelin Guide.

A labor-intensive showpiece once common in upscale French cuisine and wealthy households, aspic became more accessible with commercial gelatin and home refrigeration. By the mid-20th century, savory molds filled with meat, seafood, vegetables or hard-boiled eggs became a fashionable centerpiece at gatherings.

Aspics have made a recent comeback as home cooks explore nostalgic dishes and fine-dining chefs reimagine them as edible art.

Thanksgiving dishes that have gone to the wayside over the years

Savory aspics showcased meat, seafood or vegetables suspended in molded gelatin.

5. Cranberry Surprise

The mayonnaise company Hellmann's promoted this molded holiday gelatin "salad" in a 1958 ad, according to reports.

Made with cranberry sauce, gelatin, mayonnaise, fruit and nuts, "Cranberry Souffle Salad" was chilled, whipped until fluffy and served on lettuce.

A separate 1960 Hellmann's ad featured cranberry "candles," made with a similar mixture, molded in juice cans and topped with lit birthday candles, Bon Appétit reported.

Thanksgiving dishes that have gone to the wayside over the years

6. Hot Dr Pepper

In the 1950s and 1960s, Dr Pepper promoted the hot winter beverage, which called for heating the soda up to approximately 180 degrees Fahrenheit and then pouring it over a slice of lemon, as a way to boost sales during the slower winter months.

Grandfather carves turkey at dining room table with three-generation family seated around him.
Many vintage recipes transformed everyday ingredients into elaborate dishes for the holiday table.

The idea originated in September 1958, when company president Wesby R. Parker visited a bottling plant during a blizzard and a salesman joked that they needed a hot beverage to sell during cold weather, according to the Dr Pepper Museum.

Thanksgiving dishes that have gone to the wayside over the years